Sign Up

Browse
Browse

Have an account? Sign In Now

Sign In

Forgot Password?

Don't have account, Sign Up Here

Forgot Password

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.

Have an account? Sign In Now

You must login to ask a question.

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here

Sorry, you do not have permission to add post.

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here

Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.

mdpathyqa Logo mdpathyqa Logo
Sign InSign Up

mdpathyqa

mdpathyqa Navigation

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Search
Ask A Question

Mobile menu

Close
Ask A Question
  • Questions
  • Complaint
  • Groups
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Case taking

Case taking

This category represents questions on case-taking.

Share
  • Facebook
27 Followers
444 Answers
439 Questions

Case taking

Home/Homoeopathy/Case taking/Page 18
  • Recent Questions
  • Most Answered
  • Answers
  • No Answers
  • Most Visited
  • Most Voted
  • Random
  • Bump Question
  • New Questions
  • Sticky Questions
  • Polls
  • Recent Questions With Time
  • Most Answered With Time
  • Answers With Time
  • No Answers With Time
  • Most Visited With Time
  • Most Voted With Time
  • Random With Time
  • Bump Question With Time
  • New Questions With Time
  • Sticky Questions With Time
  • Polls With Time
  • Followed Questions
  • Favorite Questions
  • Followed Questions With Time
  • Favorite Questions With Time
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Organon, Repertory

What are the difference between totality of symptoms and total number of symptoms?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

symptomstotal numbertotality
  • 0
  • 1
  • 95
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    In homeopathy two very different concepts lurk behind similar words: 1. “Total number of symptoms” (Quantitative Totality) - A simple count of every sign and symptom the patient can list—headache, backache, thirst, dreams, skin eruptions, etc. - Treats each symptom as equal in weight: “I have 25 symRead more

    In homeopathy two very different concepts lurk behind similar words:

    1. “Total number of symptoms” (Quantitative Totality)
    – A simple count of every sign and symptom the patient can list—headache, backache, thirst, dreams, skin eruptions, etc.
    – Treats each symptom as equal in weight: “I have 25 symptoms in all.”
    – Useful for completeness, but blind to which symptoms truly define the patient’s individual state.

    2. “Totality of symptoms” (Qualitative Totality)
    – The living, synthetic picture formed when you select and weigh the patient’s most characteristic, peculiar and individualizing symptoms across all spheres—mental, emotional, general and local.
    – It isn’t “all 25 symptoms” but the sum‐total of those few keynote symptoms that capture the unique pattern of the patient’s disease and point to a single, simillimum remedy.

    Key differences:
    • Enumeration vs essence
    – Total number = how many
    – Totality = which and why they matter

    • Quantity vs quality
    – Total number sees each symptom equally
    – Totality highlights high-grade, strange, peculiar symptoms and modalities that make the case unique

    • Data gathering vs remedy prescription
    – Counting symptoms ensures you haven’t missed anything
    – Synthesizing the totality steers you to the one most similar remedy for lasting cure.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Organon, Repertory

What are the qualities required for a physician in recording a case?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

case takingphysicianqualities
  • 0
  • 1
  • 62
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Here are the key qualities a physician should uphold when recording a case: • Clear, accurate, contemporaneous and legible documentation: Records must be written in real time, using unambiguous language and handwriting (or electronic entries) that colleagues can easily read and act upon. • CompletenRead more

    Here are the key qualities a physician should uphold when recording a case:

    • Clear, accurate, contemporaneous and legible documentation: Records must be written in real time, using unambiguous language and handwriting (or electronic entries) that colleagues can easily read and act upon.

    • Completeness: Capture all pertinent details—patient history, both normal and abnormal exam findings, investigations, treatments proposed or given, patient concerns/preferences, and agreed-upon actions—to ensure continuity and safety of care.

    • Timeliness: Enter notes as soon as possible after each encounter to preserve the integrity of information and minimize omissions or memory lapses.

    • Accountability: Every entry should bear the physician’s full name, professional designation, signature (or initials), date and time, making the author of the record clearly identifiable and responsible.

    • Objectivity & factual language: Stick to descriptive, nonjudgmental terminology; avoid personal opinions or emotive wording to maintain professional and legal standards.

    • Confidentiality & security: Adhere strictly to patient-privacy laws and institutional policies, ensuring records are accessed and shared only by authorized team members.

    • Standardized format & structure: Use a consistent framework (e.g., SOAP notes, admission templates) so that any clinician reviewing the record can quickly locate and understand critical information.

    IN HOMOEOPATHY
    In homeopathy, precise, unbiased, and comprehensive case‐recording is the bedrock of remedy selection and cure. A physician must cultivate the following qualities:

    1. Empathetic, Attentive “Receiving”
    • Adopt a welcoming, patient‐centered presence—humble, unhurried and fully present—so the patient freely shares even the subtlest sensations and life‐story nuances.

    2. Faithful Transcription of Patient’s Own Words
    • Record verbatim expressions—phrases, metaphors or exclamations—as used by the patient (and attendants) to preserve their exact meaning and avoid introducing bias through rephrasing.

    3. Meticulous Completeness
    • Capture the full “totality” of symptoms—mental, emotional, physical, general constitution, modalities (what makes symptoms better or worse), concomitants and miasmatic indicators.
    • Include everything from appetite/thirst patterns, dreams and thermals to past infections, family history and environmental exposures.
    • Organize data chronologically and by rubric (e.g., mental, general, local) to facilitate repertorization.

    4. Clarity, Legibility & Timeliness
    • Make entries immediately or very soon after the encounter, using clear, unambiguous language or neat handwriting (or electronic text).
    • Date and time each note; sign or initial it to ensure accountability.

    5. Professional Discipline & Confidentiality
    • Use a bound case record or secured digital folder; avoid erasures or loose sheets so the evolution of symptoms and prescriptions remains traceable.
    • Store records in compliance with privacy standards, sharing only with authorized collaborators.

    6. Analytical Rigor
    • Highlight peculiar, rare or characteristic symptoms—these “keynotes” carry greatest weight in remedy selection.
    • Note any obstacles to cure (concomitant medications, lifestyle factors) and flag them for management.

    By embodying empathy, precision, thoroughness and disciplined record‐keeping, the homeopathic physician builds the rich, nuanced case‐picture Hahnemann deemed essential for selecting the single most similar remedy.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Disease, Homoeopathic philosophy, Miasma, Organon, Repertory

What are the direction given by Dr.Hehnemann for making case taking of chronic disease?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

case takingchronic diseases
  • 0
  • 1
  • 81
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Below are the key instructions Hahnemann gives in the Organon (Aphorisms 82–84, 204–209) for taking the case of a chronic disease: 1. Investigate past venereal infections first. “Before commencing the treatment of a chronic disease, it is necessary to make the most careful investigation as to whetheRead more

    Below are the key instructions Hahnemann gives in the Organon (Aphorisms 82–84, 204–209) for taking the case of a chronic disease:

    1. Investigate past venereal infections first.
    “Before commencing the treatment of a chronic disease, it is necessary to make the most careful investigation as to whether the patient has had a venereal infection (syphilis or gonorrhoea), for then the treatment must be directed towards this alone”.

    2. Record only the “unmodified” natural symptoms.
    To get a true evolutionary picture, note only those symptoms the patient suffered before any remedy was taken. Where necessary, pause all medications for several days so drug effects clear and the genuine symptom‐totality emerges.

    3. Document lifestyle, occupation, diet & environment.
    Scrutinize the patient’s usual modes of living—work, domestic situation, diet, habits and exposures—to identify what tends to produce or maintain the chronic complaint.

    4. Chart chronology, modalities & concomitants.
    For every symptom, record its time of onset, duration, periodicity, aggravating and ameliorating factors, and any concomitant sensations or symptoms; these particulars form the “totality” essential for remedy selection.

    5. Capture mental, emotional and general symptoms.
    Hahnemann insists on including the patient’s mental state, desires/aversions, thermals (heat/chill), thirst, sleep patterns and energy levels alongside local complaints—those “idiosyncrasies” that make each case unique.

    6. Identify the miasmatic background.
    Based on the history of recurrent patterns and the depth/severity of the disease, determine whether the predominant miasm is psoric, sycotic or syphilitic; this guides the choice and potency of the constitutional remedy (Organon §§206–209).

    By following these steps—prioritizing unaltered chronic symptoms, mapping lifestyle and modalities in meticulous detail, and classifying the underlying miasm—you compile the individualized, comprehensive case‐picture that Hahnemann saw as indispensable to homeopathic cure.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Disease, Homoeopathic philosophy, Organon, Pathology, Repertory

How should a patient be examined?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

.

case taking
  • 0
  • 1
  • 72
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Here’s a concise, systematic approach to examining any patient—whether it’s for a routine check‐up or diagnostic workup: 1. Preparation & Rapport - Wash hands, don gloves as needed. - Introduce yourself, confirm patient identity (name, DOB). - Explain the purpose and sequence of the exam; obtainRead more

    Here’s a concise, systematic approach to examining any patient—whether it’s for a routine check‐up or diagnostic workup:

    1. Preparation & Rapport
    – Wash hands, don gloves as needed.
    – Introduce yourself, confirm patient identity (name, DOB).
    – Explain the purpose and sequence of the exam; obtain consent.
    – Ensure privacy and adequate lighting; have patient in a gown if required.

    2. General Inspection & Vital Signs
    – Observe overall appearance: posture, gait, level of distress, nutrition, hygiene.
    – Record temperature, pulse, respiratory rate and blood pressure; note SpO₂ if relevant.
    – Check height, weight and calculate BMI.

    3. Head‐to‐Toe Physical Exam
    A. Head & Neck
    – Inspect scalp, hair, facial symmetry; palpate lymph nodes, thyroid.
    – Examine eyes (PERRL, fundi), ears, nose, throat and oral mucosa.
    B. Chest & Lungs
    – Observe respiratory pattern; percuss and auscultate all lung fields bilaterally.
    C. Cardiovascular
    – Inspect precordium; palpate PMI, pulses (radial, femoral, dorsalis pedis).
    – Auscultate heart in all four areas (aortic, pulmonic, tricuspid, mitral), noting rate, rhythm and any murmurs.
    D. Abdomen
    – Inspect for distension, scars; auscultate bowel sounds in all quadrants.
    – Percuss for tympany vs. dullness; palpate lightly then deeply for tenderness or masses.
    E. Extremities & Peripheral Vascular
    – Check joint range of motion, muscle bulk and tone.
    – Assess edema, skin changes, capillary refill and peripheral pulses.
    F. Neurological Screen
    – Assess mental status, cranial nerves, motor strength, sensation, reflexes, gait and coordination.
    G. Skin
    – Inspect entire skin surface for rashes, lesions, color changes and turgor.

    4. Focused Systems or Special Tests
    – Tailor additional maneuvers to presenting complaints (e.g., CVA tenderness, meningeal signs, joint special tests, pelvic exam).

    5. Documentation & Next Steps
    – Record all findings immediately—normal and abnormal.
    – Summarize impressions, recommend further investigation (labs, imaging) or referrals.
    – Discuss findings and plan with the patient, answering any questions.

    By following this head-to-toe, reproducible sequence you’ll ensure no key system is missed—and you’ll build trust by communicating clearly at each step.

    IN HOMOEOPATHY
    Below is the classic structure for a homeopathic patient examination—rooted in Organon principles and lectures by Stuart Close and J.T. Kent.

    1. Establish the Purpose
    “The purpose of a homeopathic examination is to elicit every symptom—mental, emotional and physical—in the patient’s own language so these can be compared with the materia medica for remedy selection.”

    2. Open‐Ended Case‐Taking
    • Invite the patient (and family if needed) to narrate complaints without interruption, using their exact words for key phrases.
    • Exhort slow, thorough description to capture nuances of sensation, location, intensity and concomitants.
    • Note modalities—what makes symptoms better or worse (e.g., heat, cold, motion, time of day).

    3. Systematic Symptom Classification
    Divide your notes into columns or headings, for rapid visual scanning:
    • Date/Prescription (to track progress)
    • Emphatic headings (mental, general, local)
    • Detailed symptom entries (verbatim when possible)

    4. Mental & Emotional Sphere
    • Mood (anxious, irritable, apathetic, fearful)
    • Thought processes (obsessions, clarity, memory lapses)
    • Desires/aversions (food, thirst, temperature, company vs. solitude)

    5. Physical Generals
    • Thermals (hot vs. chilly), thirst (quantity, frequency, temperature of fluids), sweat (profuse vs. scanty).
    • Stools, urine, sleep patterns and dreams.
    • Energy levels, posture, gait.

    6. Local/Objective Signs
    • Inspection: skin, tongue, eyes, nails, gait.
    • Palpation/percussion as needed (abdomen, lymph nodes).
    • Vital signs: pulse quality, blood pressure, respiration.

    7. Concomitants & Peculiarities
    • Any symptom that accompanies the chief complaint but seems unrelated (e.g., a headache whenever the back pain flares).
    • Strange, rare, peculiar symptoms carry the greatest weight in remedy selection.

    8. Miasmatic & Constitutional Assessment
    • Identify dominant miasm (psoric, sycotic, syphilitic) based on history of recurrent patterns and depth of disease.
    • Note constitutional type—tall vs. short, lean vs. stout, swift vs. slow metabolism.

    9. Repertorization & Remedy Confirmation
    • After full symptom capture, select rubrics in a repertory, giving priority to totality of picture and highest‐grade peculiarities.
    • Cross-check final remedy choice in the materia medica for confirming key keynote symptoms.

    10. Record‐Keeping & Follow-Up
    • Keep prescription dates and potencies clearly logged.
    • Re-examine every 2–4 weeks: note changes in symptom intensity, disappearance of key rubrics, emergence of new modalities.
    • Adjust potency or change remedy based on evolving totality.

    By meticulously documenting subjective and objective data in the patient’s own words, then classifying and repertorizing, a homeopath arrives at the single most similar remedy for lasting cure.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Miasma, Organon, Repertory

What is the advice of Dr.Hahnemann about the treatment of alternating disease?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

alternating diseasetreatment
  • 0
  • 1
  • 114
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Dr. Hahnemann treats “alternating” (i.e. periodically shifting) acute diseases almost exactly like simple acute diseases—with one proviso: you prescribe only for whatever set of symptoms is on top at the moment of prescribing, and then wait for the next phase to treat that in turn. In his own wordsRead more

    Dr. Hahnemann treats “alternating” (i.e. periodically shifting) acute diseases almost exactly like simple acute diseases—with one proviso: you prescribe only for whatever set of symptoms is on top at the moment of prescribing, and then wait for the next phase to treat that in turn. In his own words (Organon § 72–73):

    1. Acute diseases come in three types:
    a) Simple (one fixed picture)
    b) Composite (two or more pictures at once)
    c) Alternating (two or more pictures that appear one after the other)

    2. For simple and composite acute diseases you select the one single homeopathic remedy that covers the totality of symptoms most accurately.

    3. For alternating diseases you never try to “cover” both alternating pictures at once. Instead you:
    • Wait for the patient’s symptoms to decide which phase (A or B) is active.
    • Give solely the homeopathic remedy that corresponds to that present phase.
    • Then cease and observe—when the other phase re-establishes itself you similarly give the remedy that fits that new picture.

    By doing this, you never mix or dilute the vital force’s reaction with competing stimuli, but rather allow each diseased phase to be repelled in turn.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
1 … 17 18 19 … 88

Sidebar

Ask A Question

Stats

  • Questions 2k
  • Answers 2k
  • Posts 26
  • Comments 4
  • Best Answers 11
  • Users 6k
  • Groups 13
  • Group Posts 4
  • Popular
  • Answers
  • Esrat

    Explanation Hahnemann's work from materialistic, spiritualistic, idealistic or vitalistic ...

    • 4 Answers
  • Dr Beauty Akther

    What are the aims of philosophy?

    • 2 Answers
  • Dr Beauty Akther

    Write down the different method of dynamisation.

    • 3 Answers
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Selection of Dose and Potency in Acute vs. Chronic Disease:… July 13, 2026 at 2:04 pm
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Case Taking in Homoeopathy: The Holistic Lens In homoeopathy, case… July 13, 2026 at 1:40 pm
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Primary Manifestation of Psora — Homoeopathic View The Core Idea… July 13, 2026 at 1:19 pm

Top Members

Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH

Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH

  • 0 Questions
  • 764 Points
Enlightened
Dr Beauty Akther

Dr Beauty Akther

  • 365 Questions
  • 148 Points
Pundit
Zannat

Zannat

  • 83 Questions
  • 27 Points
Begginer

Questions Categories

Disease
33Followers
Repertory
26Followers
Materia Medica
33Followers
Pathology
32Followers
Case taking
27Followers
Miasma
27Followers
Homoeopathic philosophy
25Followers
Organon
26Followers
Gynecology
31Followers
Microbiology
31Followers
Psychology
23Followers
Surgery
31Followers
Public Health
24Followers
Homoeopathic pharmacy
23Followers
Language
17Followers
Homoeopathy
19Followers
Obstetrics
24Followers
Human Behavior
27Followers
Research Methodology
19Followers
Analytics
21Followers
Physiology
16Followers
Forensic Medicine
21Followers
Technology
29Followers
Education
32Followers
Health
31Followers
Management
20Followers
Food & health
22Followers
Human Progress
25Followers
Hypothetical Personal Situations
21Followers
Dreams and Dreaming
33Followers
History
7Followers
Programmers
17Followers
The Holly Quran
13Followers
The Noble Quran
13Followers
Tissue remedies
21Followers
Anatomy
15Followers
Company
18Followers
Visiting and Travel
28Followers
University
17Followers
Reading
21Followers
Grammar
24Followers
Programs
17Followers
Communication
18Followers
Contents
Last update: 13/05/26

Explore

  • Questions
  • Complaint
  • Groups
  • Blog

Footer

mdpathyqa

mdpathyqa is a social & Answers Engine which will help you establis your community and connect with other people.

Help

  • Knowledge Base
  • Knowledge Base
  • Support
  • Support

Follow

Footer 1

2024 microdoshomoeo. All Rights Reserved
With Love by microdoshomoeo

Latest Activity: discuss about selection of dose and potency in case of acute and chronic disease.