Sign Up

Browse
Browse

Have an account? Sign In Now

Sign In

Forgot Password?

Don't have account, Sign Up Here

Forgot Password

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.

Have an account? Sign In Now

You must login to ask a question.

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here

Sorry, you do not have permission to add post.

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here

Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.

mdpathyqa Logo mdpathyqa Logo
Sign InSign Up

mdpathyqa

mdpathyqa Navigation

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Search
Ask A Question

Mobile menu

Close
Ask A Question
  • Questions
  • Complaint
  • Groups
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Case taking

Case taking

This category represents questions on case-taking.

Share
  • Facebook
27 Followers
444 Answers
439 Questions

Case taking

Home/Homoeopathy/Case taking/Page 16
  • Recent Questions
  • Most Answered
  • Answers
  • No Answers
  • Most Visited
  • Most Voted
  • Random
  • Bump Question
  • New Questions
  • Sticky Questions
  • Polls
  • Recent Questions With Time
  • Most Answered With Time
  • Answers With Time
  • No Answers With Time
  • Most Visited With Time
  • Most Voted With Time
  • Random With Time
  • Bump Question With Time
  • New Questions With Time
  • Sticky Questions With Time
  • Polls With Time
  • Followed Questions
  • Favorite Questions
  • Followed Questions With Time
  • Favorite Questions With Time
Asked: 1 year agoIn: Analytics, Case taking, Disease, Homoeopathic philosophy, Miasma, Organon, Pathology

What do you mean by curable and incurable disease? Discuss their treatment?

Shameema Akter
Shameema Akter

curableincurabletreatment
  • 0
  • 1
  • 30
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Teacher dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Curable vs Incurable Diseases Definitions Curable diseases are those in which homeopathic treatment can lead to the complete and permanent restoration of health by removing the underlying imbalance that causes the illness. These conditions typically have functional or reversible pathology, respond rRead more

    Curable vs Incurable Diseases

    Definitions

    Curable diseases are those in which homeopathic treatment can lead to the complete and permanent restoration of health by removing the underlying imbalance that causes the illness. These conditions typically have functional or reversible pathology, respond reliably to the simillimum, and show sustained improvement after therapy.

    Incurable diseases refer to chronic or irreversible pathological states where full cure may not be achievable. Homeopathy in these cases focuses on palliation—alleviating symptoms, reducing suffering, and improving quality of life—even if the disease’s fundamental process cannot be entirely eradicated.

    Treatment Approaches:

    Curable Conditions:

    Homoeopathic management of curable diseases centers on:

    – Totality of Symptoms
    Gathering comprehensive mental, emotional, and physical symptom data to identify the single most similar remedy (simillimum).
    – Potency Selection & Repetition
    Choosing a potency that matches the patient’s vitality and repeating it according to the case dynamics.
    – Correct Remedy
    Precise selection based on symptom picture leads to rapid, gentle, and permanent results.
    – Monitoring & Follow-up
    Adjusting treatment as the patient’s symptom picture evolves until complete cure is achieved.

    These steps can transform acute and many chronic functional disorders—such as eczema, migraines, or allergic rhinitis—into fully resolved states when handled systematically.

    Incurable Conditions:

    When faced with irreversible pathology—advanced cancers, end-stage organ failures, or entrenched autoimmune diseases—homeopathy shifts to palliative care. The goals are:

    – Relieve pain and discomfort
    – Slow disease progression
    – Enhance overall well-being
    – Minimize side effects of conventional treatments

    Example of some common Palliative Remedies:
    1. Conium maculatum- Mitigates muscular spasms and pain in scirrhous tumors
    2. Carbo animalis- Eases stinging, burning pains and night sweats in cancerous conditions
    3. Phosphorus- Controls bleeding and palliates pain in carcinomas with hemorrhage
    4. Chamomilla- Helps in colicky, spasmodic pains when patients are oversensitive to pain
    5. China officinalis- Addresses weakness and pain after fluid loss (e.g., postoperative, shock states)
    6. Berberis vulgaris- Alleviates biliary and renal colic as an alternative to morphine
    7. Silicea terra- Palliates pain of unbroken scirrhus and supports ulcerated malignancies locally

    Integrated Care

    – Combination Therapies
    Pairing homeopathy with modalities like acupuncture or low-dose physiologic drugs for enhanced comfort.
    – Supportive Measures
    Nutrition optimization, stress management, and gentle physical therapies.
    – Patient-Centered Monitoring
    Frequent reassessments to tailor palliative remedies as the disease evolves.

    Homeopathic treatment, whether aimed at cure or palliation, always adheres to the law of similars. For curable diseases, it seeks the simillimum to restore health completely. In incurable or terminal cases, it employs similar principles to provide the gentlest, longest-lasting relief without the toxic after-effects of conventional stimulants and analgesics.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Materia Medica, Miasma, Organon, Repertory

What a medicine which is through a of hydrogenoid constitution, yet feels better in damp weather?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

constitutionhydrogenoid
  • 0
  • 1
  • 130
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Natrum sulphuricum – the classic Grauvogl “hydrogenoid” remedy – is characteristically better in damp, wet weather.

    Natrum sulphuricum – the classic Grauvogl “hydrogenoid” remedy – is characteristically better in damp, wet weather.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Organon, Repertory, Surgery

What are the services of the dynamic physician for the true surgical diseases?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

surgical disease
  • 0
  • 2
  • 65
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    In classical homeopathy “true surgical diseases” (fractures, abscesses needing incision, deep lacerations, tumors, foreign bodies, etc.) lie outside the curative province of pure dynamic treatment. The homeopathic—or “dynamic”—physician’s role is entirely supportive and palliative, working alongsideRead more

    In classical homeopathy “true surgical diseases” (fractures, abscesses needing incision, deep lacerations, tumors, foreign bodies, etc.) lie outside the curative province of pure dynamic treatment. The homeopathic—or “dynamic”—physician’s role is entirely supportive and palliative, working alongside the surgeon to strengthen the vital force, alleviate suffering and speed natural repair:

    1. Discrimination & Referral
    • Recognize purely mechanical lesions that demand surgical or mechanical intervention (Organon §§13, 29).
    • Refer promptly for the appropriate operative procedure rather than attempting primary cure by remedies alone.

    2. Pre‐ and Post‐Operative Palliative Care
    • Pre‐op: Aconitum napellus for fear, restlessness, shock; Arnica montana to minimize surgical trauma and bleeding tendencies.
    • Post‐op:
    – Arnica montana: reduce hidden bruising, pain on movement, shock to the vital force.
    – Calendula officinalis: antiseptic action—promote clean granulation and prevent septic complications.
    – Hypericum perforatum: nerve‐rich wounds, lancinating pains, puncture injuries.
    – Bellis perennis: deep‐seated contusions, periarticular injuries (e.g., hip, gluteal abscesses).
    – Ledum palustre: puncture wounds, animal bites, to prevent tetanic or septic spread.
    – Hepar sulphuris calcareum: when wounds become indolent, over-suppurating or painfully sensitive to touch.
    – Silicea terra: drives out retained foreign matter, hastens expulsion of slough, supports closure of chronic sinuses.

    3. Managing Inflammation, Pain & Edema
    • Bryonia alba: stitching pains worse on motion, dryness of membranes.
    • Rhus toxicodendron: swelling, stiffness relieved by continued motion or warm applications.
    • Apis mellifica: stinging, burning edema, hypersensitivity to touch.

    4. Controlling Hemorrhage & Infection
    • Hamamelis virginica: venous bleeding, varicosities, oozing wounds.
    • Arnica + Hamamelis combination: blunt trauma with capillary rupture.
    • Carbo vegetabilis: putrid discharges, coldness of surface, prurient infections.

    5. Supporting Nutrition & General Vitality
    • Encourage high-protein diet, vitamins A/C, zinc and adequate hydration to fuel collagen synthesis and immune response.
    • Address post-surgical debility with gentle tonics—China officinalis (after blood loss), Phosphorus (post-anesthetic weakness), Calcarea phosphorica (bone healing).

    6. Monitoring & Adjusting Therapy
    • Reassess wound progress weekly: note granulation quality, degree of inflammation, discharge character.
    • Change or add remedies if healing stalls—e.g., switch from Hepar sulph. to Silicea when pus diminishes but cavity persists.

    By confining homeopathy to its dynamic sphere—never replacing the surgeon’s scalpel—the physician aids the vis medicatrix naturae in restoring integrity, reducing scarring, preventing septic sequelae and hastening full recovery.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Disease, Homoeopathic philosophy, Organon, Pathology, Surgery

What are the opinion of Dr.Hahnemann about the treatment of surgical disease?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

surgical disease
  • 0
  • 1
  • 97
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Dr. Hahnemann clearly separates “surgical diseases” from those curable by pure homeopathic (dynamic) means. His key points are: 1. Classification of Diseases (Organon §7-footnote; §§13, 29) – He divides all maladies into: a) Reluctance (slight, self-limiting disorders) b) Surgical diseases (purely mRead more

    Dr. Hahnemann clearly separates “surgical diseases” from those curable by pure homeopathic (dynamic) means. His key points are:

    1. Classification of Diseases (Organon §7-footnote; §§13, 29)
    – He divides all maladies into:
    a) Reluctance (slight, self-limiting disorders)
    b) Surgical diseases (purely mechanical lesions)
    c) Dynamic diseases (acute & chronic miasmatic conditions).
    – Only the last group falls wholly within homeopathy’s curative scope.

    2. Surgical Diseases Require Mechanical Aid (Organon §§13 & 29)
    – “Pure surgical diseases” (fractures, lacerations, abscesses needing incision, dislocations, amputations, etc.) are not dynamic in origin but result from external trauma or tissue discontinuity.
    – Such cases “do not belong to the province of the physician” acting by dynamic law, but to that of the surgeon, and must be treated by mechanical or operative means alone.

    3. Homeopathy’s Role Is Ancillary
    – Hahnemann allows homeopathic remedies only as palliatives or adjuvants: to alleviate pain, control inflammation and support reparative processes after proper mechanical intervention.
    – Common choices include Arnica montana for traumatic bruising/pain, Calendula for wound antisepsis and Silicea or Hepar sulphuris for sluggish or suppurating ulcers.

    4. Physician’s Duty
    – The homeopath must recognize when surgical aid is indispensable, refer or co-manage appropriately, and limit remedy use to what assists the “vis medicatrix naturae” post-surgery rather than attempting to replace it.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Human Behavior, Miasma, Organon, Repertory

What are the necessity to observe the constitution and behaviour of the patient in preparing a case history?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

behaviorcase takingconstitution
  • 0
  • 1
  • 92
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    In classical homeopathy, noting a patient’s constitution (their physical make-up, temperament and innate susceptibilities) and behaviour (their habitual mental–emotional reactions and life-style patterns) is indispensable when taking a case history. Here’s why: 1. Enables true individualization A reRead more

    In classical homeopathy, noting a patient’s constitution (their physical make-up, temperament and innate susceptibilities) and behaviour (their habitual mental–emotional reactions and life-style patterns) is indispensable when taking a case history. Here’s why:

    1. Enables true individualization
    A remedy must match the patient as a whole person—body, mind and spirit—not just the disease. Observing constitutional traits (e.g. lean vs. stout build; rapid vs. slow metabolism; tendency to chill or heat) plus behavioural tendencies (anxious vs. placid temperament; social vs. withdrawn) lets you distinguish one individual’s totality from another’s.

    2. Shapes the “totality of symptoms”
    Constitutional and behavioural details often supply the most characteristic, peculiar rubrics in your case—those rare or striking traits (“keynotes”) that carry greatest weight in repertorization. Without them, you risk ending up with a generic prescription that won’t act as deeply or lastingly.

    3. Guides remedy selection and potency
    Some remedies are well-known for particular constitutional types (e.g., Pulsatilla in gentle, changeable temperaments; Calcarea carbonica in sluggish, chilly individuals). Recognizing these patterns steers you toward the small circle of likely similars and helps choose an appropriate potency and dosing frequency.

    4. Reveals susceptibility and miasmatic background
    Physical constitution and behavioural patterns point to deeper predispositions—psoric (hypersensitive, restless), sycotic (stubborn, secretive), or syphilitic (destructive, profound change). Identifying the dominant miasm is essential for depth of action and cure retention.

    5. Predicts obstacles and prognosis
    A patient’s lifestyle habits (eating, sleeping, stress-coping) and behavioural coping strategies can hinder or aid remedy action. Early recognition allows you to counsel on diet, rest, emotional outlets and other supports, making your prescription more effective and your prognosis realistic.

    By carefully observing and documenting constitution and behaviour, you assemble the rich, nuanced case-picture Hahnemann deemed essential: only then can you select the one remedy most truly “like” your patient’s living totality—and achieve a lasting cure.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
1 … 15 16 17 … 88

Sidebar

Ask A Question

Stats

  • Questions 2k
  • Answers 2k
  • Posts 26
  • Comments 4
  • Best Answers 11
  • Users 6k
  • Groups 13
  • Group Posts 4
  • Popular
  • Answers
  • Esrat

    Explanation Hahnemann's work from materialistic, spiritualistic, idealistic or vitalistic ...

    • 4 Answers
  • Dr Beauty Akther

    What are the aims of philosophy?

    • 2 Answers
  • Dr Beauty Akther

    Write down the different method of dynamisation.

    • 3 Answers
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Selection of Dose and Potency in Acute vs. Chronic Disease:… July 13, 2026 at 2:04 pm
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Case Taking in Homoeopathy: The Holistic Lens In homoeopathy, case… July 13, 2026 at 1:40 pm
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Primary Manifestation of Psora — Homoeopathic View The Core Idea… July 13, 2026 at 1:19 pm

Top Members

Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH

Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH

  • 0 Questions
  • 764 Points
Enlightened
Dr Beauty Akther

Dr Beauty Akther

  • 365 Questions
  • 148 Points
Pundit
Zannat

Zannat

  • 83 Questions
  • 27 Points
Begginer

Questions Categories

Disease
33Followers
Repertory
26Followers
Materia Medica
33Followers
Pathology
32Followers
Case taking
27Followers
Miasma
27Followers
Homoeopathic philosophy
25Followers
Organon
26Followers
Gynecology
31Followers
Microbiology
31Followers
Psychology
23Followers
Surgery
31Followers
Public Health
24Followers
Homoeopathic pharmacy
23Followers
Language
17Followers
Homoeopathy
19Followers
Obstetrics
24Followers
Human Behavior
27Followers
Research Methodology
19Followers
Analytics
21Followers
Physiology
16Followers
Forensic Medicine
21Followers
Technology
29Followers
Education
32Followers
Health
31Followers
Management
20Followers
Food & health
22Followers
Human Progress
25Followers
Hypothetical Personal Situations
21Followers
Dreams and Dreaming
33Followers
History
7Followers
Programmers
17Followers
The Holly Quran
13Followers
The Noble Quran
13Followers
Tissue remedies
21Followers
Anatomy
15Followers
Company
18Followers
Visiting and Travel
28Followers
University
17Followers
Reading
21Followers
Grammar
24Followers
Programs
17Followers
Communication
18Followers
Contents
Last update: 13/05/26

Explore

  • Questions
  • Complaint
  • Groups
  • Blog

Footer

mdpathyqa

mdpathyqa is a social & Answers Engine which will help you establis your community and connect with other people.

Help

  • Knowledge Base
  • Knowledge Base
  • Support
  • Support

Follow

Footer 1

2024 microdoshomoeo. All Rights Reserved
With Love by microdoshomoeo

Latest Activity: discuss about selection of dose and potency in case of acute and chronic disease.