Sign Up

Browse
Browse

Have an account? Sign In Now

Sign In

Forgot Password?

Don't have account, Sign Up Here

Forgot Password

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.

Have an account? Sign In Now

You must login to ask a question.

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here

Sorry, you do not have permission to add post.

Forgot Password?

Need An Account, Sign Up Here

Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.

Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.

mdpathyqa Logo mdpathyqa Logo
Sign InSign Up

mdpathyqa

mdpathyqa Navigation

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Search
Ask A Question

Mobile menu

Close
Ask A Question
  • Questions
  • Complaint
  • Groups
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
Case taking

Case taking

This category represents questions on case-taking.

Share
  • Facebook
27 Followers
444 Answers
439 Questions

Case taking

Home/Homoeopathy/Case taking/Page 14
  • Recent Questions
  • Most Answered
  • Answers
  • No Answers
  • Most Visited
  • Most Voted
  • Random
  • Bump Question
  • New Questions
  • Sticky Questions
  • Polls
  • Recent Questions With Time
  • Most Answered With Time
  • Answers With Time
  • No Answers With Time
  • Most Visited With Time
  • Most Voted With Time
  • Random With Time
  • Bump Question With Time
  • New Questions With Time
  • Sticky Questions With Time
  • Polls With Time
  • Followed Questions
  • Favorite Questions
  • Followed Questions With Time
  • Favorite Questions With Time
Asked: 11 months agoIn: Case taking, Organon, Repertory

What is the important points of Aphorism 183?

Dr Beauty Akther
Dr Beauty AktherPundit

aphorism 183reassessment after remedy ceases to actsecond prescription
  • 0
  • 1
  • 20
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 11 months ago

    § 183 Whenever, therefore, the dose of the first medicine ceases to have a beneficial effect (if the newly developed symptoms do not, by reason of their gravity, demand more speedy aid – which, however, from the minuteness of the dose of homoeopathic medicine, and in very chronic diseases, is excessRead more

    § 183
    Whenever, therefore, the dose of the first medicine ceases to have a beneficial effect (if the newly developed symptoms do not, by reason of their gravity, demand more speedy aid – which, however, from the minuteness of the dose of homoeopathic medicine, and in very chronic diseases, is excessively rare), a new examination of the disease must be instituted, the status morbi as it now is must be noted down, and a second homoeopathic remedy selected in accordance with it, which shall exactly suit the present state, and one which shall be all the more appropriate can then be found, as the group of symptoms has become larger and more complete.

    Aphorism 183 from Hahnemann’s Organon of Medicine provides guidance on what to do when the first prescribed remedy no longer produces beneficial effects. Here are the most important points:

    🔍 Key Points of Aphorism 183

    1. Reassessment After Remedy Ceases to Act
    – When the first remedy stops working, the physician must re-examine the case.
    – A fresh assessment of the current state of the disease (status morbi) is essential.

    2. Selection of a New Remedy
    – Based on the updated symptom picture, a second homoeopathic remedy should be chosen.
    – This new remedy must be better suited to the present condition of the patient.

    3. Expanded Symptom Picture
    – After the first remedy, the group of symptoms often becomes larger and clearer.
    – This makes it easier to select a more appropriate remedy for the next phase of treatment.

    4. Rare Need for Urgent Intervention
    – In very chronic diseases, urgent intervention due to newly developed symptoms is rare because of the minuteness of homeopathic doses.
    – However, if symptoms are severe and demand immediate attention, this must be addressed promptly.

    🧠 Clinical Insight

    – This aphorism emphasizes the dynamic nature of chronic disease treatment.
    – It encourages ongoing observation and flexibility, rather than rigid adherence to a single remedy.
    – The evolving symptom picture is a valuable guide for deeper healing.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 11 months agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Organon

What is the important points of Aphorism 236?

Dr Beauty Akther
Dr Beauty AktherPundit

aphorism 236timing for medication
  • 0
  • 1
  • 31
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 11 months ago
    This answer was edited.

    § 236 The most appropriate and efficacious time for administering the medicine in these cases is immediately or very soon after the termination of the paroxysm, as soon as the patient has in some degree recovered from its effects; it has then time to effect all the changes in the organism requisiteRead more

    § 236
    The most appropriate and efficacious time for administering the medicine in these cases is immediately or very soon after the termination of the paroxysm, as soon as the patient has in some degree recovered from its effects; it has then time to effect all the changes in the organism requisite for the restoration of health, without any great disturbance or violent commotion; whereas the action of a medicine, be it ever so specifically appropriate, if given immediately before the paroxysm, coincides with the natural recurrence of the disease and causes such a reaction in the organism, such a violent contention, that an attack of that nature produces at the very least a great loss of strength, if it do not endanger life.1 But if the medicine be given immediately after the termination of the fit, that is to say, at the period when the apyretic interval has commenced and a long time before there are any preparations for the next paroxysm, then the vital force of the organism is in the best possible condition to allow itself to be quietly altered by the remedy, and thus restored to the healthy state.

    Aphorism 236 from Samuel Hahnemann’s Organon of Medicine focuses on the timing of administering homeopathic remedies in cases of intermittent diseases, such as fevers with paroxysms (recurring attacks). Here are the key points:

    🔑 Important Points of Aphorism 236

    – Optimal Timing for Medication:
    – The best time to administer the remedy is immediately after the paroxysm ends, when the patient has somewhat recovered.
    – This timing allows the medicine to act gently and effectively on the organism without causing violent reactions.

    – Avoid Pre-Paroxysm Dosing:
    – Giving medicine just before a paroxysm can be harmful.
    – It may intensify the natural disease reaction, leading to violent contention within the body and potentially endangering life.

    – Vital Force Readiness:
    – After the paroxysm, during the apyretic interval (a symptom-free phase), the vital force is most receptive.
    – The organism is in a state where it can be quietly and beneficially influenced by the remedy.

    – Clinical Example:
    – Hahnemann warns against giving opium during the cold stage of a fever, citing fatal outcomes from such practice.

    This aphorism emphasizes the importance of respecting the body’s natural rhythms and choosing the least disruptive moment for therapeutic intervention.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Miasma, Organon

What are the homoeopathic treatment of one sided disease?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

one sided diseasetreatment
  • 0
  • 1
  • 86
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 11 months ago

    In homeopathy, one-sided diseases are those that present with very few symptoms, often just one or two dominant ones, making it difficult to select the correct remedy. Samuel Hahnemann, the founder of homeopathy, discusses these in detail in the Organon of Medicine, particularly in Aphorisms 172–184Read more

    In homeopathy, one-sided diseases are those that present with very few symptoms, often just one or two dominant ones, making it difficult to select the correct remedy. Samuel Hahnemann, the founder of homeopathy, discusses these in detail in the Organon of Medicine, particularly in Aphorisms 172–184.

    🧠 What Is a One-Sided Disease?

    – A condition where only a few symptoms are visible, while others are obscured or suppressed.
    – Often seen in chronic diseases, or when conventional treatments (like steroids or painkillers) mask the full symptom picture.
    – Examples include migraine, calculous cholecystitis, or localized neuralgia, where the complaint is restricted to one side or one organ.

    🏥 Homeopathic Approach to Treatment

    1. Careful Observation
    – The practitioner must observe deeply, noting even subtle physical, emotional, and behavioral traits.
    – Sometimes the first remedy is only partially effective—it helps uncover hidden symptoms, which then guide the next prescription.

    2. Use of Characteristic Symptoms
    – Remedies are chosen based on peculiar, striking, and uncommon symptoms, even if they are few.
    – The goal is to stimulate the vital force to reveal more of the disease picture.

    3. Sequential Prescribing
    – Often, a series of remedies is needed:
    – First remedy: partially effective, reveals new symptoms.
    – Second remedy: better matched to the full picture.
    – This method is especially useful in migraine cases, where remedies like Belladonna, Spigelia, or Sanguinaria may be used depending on the side and nature of pain.

    🧪 Common Remedies in One-Sided Diseases

    Right-sided migraine- Sanguinaria, Belladonna
    Left-sided neuralgia- Spigelia, Lachesis
    One-sided paralysis- Causticum, Plumbum
    Localized inflammation- Bryonia, Apis

    📘 Hahnemann’s Guidance (Organon)

    – Aphorism 173: One-sided diseases are less amenable to cure due to few symptoms.
    – Aphorism 178–181: The first remedy may provoke new symptoms, which help refine the case and guide the next prescription.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 6 years agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Miasma, Organon, Psychology, Repertory

What special responsibility are needs for the treatment of mantal disease?

Nasim
NasimBegginer

mental disease
  • 0
  • 1
  • 63
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    Special Responsibilities and Needs for Treating Mental Diseases in Homeopathy Comprehensive Case Taking Homeopathic treatment of mental disorders demands an exhaustive case history focusing on the patient’s subjective feelings, thoughts, sensations, and reactions to life stressors. This deep inquiryRead more

    Special Responsibilities and Needs for Treating Mental Diseases in Homeopathy

    Comprehensive Case Taking

    Homeopathic treatment of mental disorders demands an exhaustive case history focusing on the patient’s subjective feelings, thoughts, sensations, and reactions to life stressors. This deep inquiry uncovers the peculiar and characteristic mental symptoms essential for selecting the simillimum.

    Emphasis on Mental Symptomatology

    In homeopathy, mental symptoms are given priority over general and local signs. They are considered the truest expression of the patient’s vital disturbance, guiding individualization and precise remedy selection.

    Miasmatic Classification and Understanding

    Clinicians must recognize Hahnemann’s four psoric‐origin types of mental disease—somato‐psychic, sudden acute, doubtful origin, and prolonged psycho‐somatic—and tailor treatment strategies accordingly.

    Therapeutic Relationship and Counseling

    A strong patient–provider alliance built on unconditional positive regard, empathy, and congruence enhances trust, promotes narrative sharing, and supports transformational healing in mental health cases.

    Integration with Conventional Mental Health Care

    Homeopaths bear the responsibility to collaborate with psychiatrists and psychologists, ensuring safe co‐administration of psychotropic medications and appropriate referrals for severe or emergency conditions.

    Ethical and Legal Considerations

    Practitioners must obtain informed consent, maintain strict confidentiality, and recognize when to refer patients for specialized psychiatric or psychological interventions to safeguard patient welfare.

    Special Responsibilities for Treating Mental Diseases in the Organon of Medicine

    In Aphorisms (210–230), Hahnemann highlights that mental diseases are essentially one-sided psoric affections requiring precise observation of the mind and disposition as primary guiding symptoms. The physician’s special responsibility lies in capturing the full mental portrait and applying both homeopathic and psychical measures appropriately.

    1. Prioritizing the State of Mind and Disposition

    Homeopathic cure demands that alterations in the patient’s disposition be noted alongside all other symptoms. The state of mind often determines remedy choice, as every medicine produces a distinct mental picture in its proving.

    – Observe characteristic mood changes, fears, delusions, and anxieties
    – Record any shifts in mental state precipitated by external or internal factors
    – Treat the mind–body as an indivisible whole, never overlooking psychical symptoms

    2. Constructing a Complete Totality of Symptoms

    A thorough case includes both the obscured remnants of prior bodily disease and the now-dominant mental symptoms.

    – Gather detailed history from patient’s friends or attendants to reconstruct past corporeal symptoms
    – Compare lingering physical signs with current mental disturbances to confirm psoric transformation
    – Compile a single totality encompassing all mental and bodily phenomena before selecting a remedy

    3. Remedy Selection and Miasmatic Considerations

    Mental cases often require a two-stage approach, addressing acute eruptions first, then deep-acting anti-psoric treatment to prevent relapse.

    1. Acute onset of mania, frenzy or melancholia
    – Use non-antipsoric remedies (e.g., aconite, belladonna, hyoscyamus) in potentized minimum doses to subdue the acute phase
    2. Chronic psoric miasm
    – Follow with prolonged anti-psoric treatment once the acute symptoms are controlled
    – Reinforce cure through faithful adherence to diet and regimen

    4. Management and Psychotherapeutic Attitude

    Beyond prescribing, the physician must adopt an empathetic, strategic behavior tailored to each mental state.

    – In raging mania: exhibit calm fearlessness and firm resolution
    – In loquacity: listen in silence, offering measured attention
    – Early psychogenic emotional disorders: employ “psychical remedies” such as reassurance, sensible advice, friendly exhortation or well-planned deception alongside proper regimen to restore mental health rapidly

    By fulfilling these responsibilities—keen mental observation, meticulous totality construction, staged remedy selection, and a tailored psychotherapeutic approach—homeopaths align with Hahnemann’s vision for the successful treatment of mental disease.

    Continuous Monitoring and Follow-Up

    Regular follow-up appointments are crucial to assess progression, adjust potencies or dosing schedules, and confirm the remedy’s efficacy, ensuring dynamic alignment with the patient’s evolving mental state.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
Asked: 1 year agoIn: Case taking, Homoeopathic philosophy, Homoeopathy, Organon

What dose it mean by a true healing artist?

Dr Beauty Akther
Dr Beauty AktherPundit

true healing artist
  • 0
  • 1
  • 14
  • 0
  1. Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH Enlightened dr.basuriwala
    Added an answer about 1 year ago

    What “True Healing Artist” Means in Homeopathy In Homeopathy, the term “true healing artist” describes the practitioner who embodies the pure, experiential art of cure as laid out by Hahnemann—applying remedies with precision, minimal force, and in strict accordance with homoeopathic principles. CorRead more

    What “True Healing Artist” Means in Homeopathy

    In Homeopathy, the term “true healing artist” describes the practitioner who embodies the pure, experiential art of cure as laid out by Hahnemann—applying remedies with precision, minimal force, and in strict accordance with homoeopathic principles.

    Core Definition

    A true healing artist is one who:

    – Understands the dynamic vital force and its derangements.
    – Recognizes the totality of a patient’s symptoms—mental, emotional, and physical—and removes both exciting and maintaining causes.
    – Selects a remedy solely by similarity of symptom picture, not by conjecture or theory.
    – Administers it in the smallest conceivable dose that will still effect a curative response.

    Hahnemann’s Description (Aphorism 283 & 249, 6th Edition)

    “In order to work wholly according to nature, the true healing artist will prescribe the accurately chosen homoeopathic medicine most suitable in all respects in so small a dose on account of this alone. For should he be misled by human weakness to employ an unsuitable medicine, the disadvantage of its wrong relation to the disease would be so small that the patient could through his own vital powers and by means of early opposition (§ 249) of the correctly chosen remedy according to symptom similarly (and this also in the smallest dose) rapidly extinguish and repair it.”

    Key points from this aphorism:

    – Remedies must be accurate in their picture of the disease.
    – Dosage must be minimal, so that if a mistake occurs, the organism can self-correct.
    – Treatment must adhere to natural law, avoiding suppression or palliation of symptoms.

    Aphorism 249
    Every medicine prescribed for a case of disease which, in the course of its action, produces new and troublesome symptoms not appertaining to the disease to be cured, is not capable of effecting real improvement, and cannot be considered as homoeopathically selected; it must, therefore, either, if the aggravation be considerable, be first partially neutralized as soon as possible by an antidote before giving the next remedy chosen more accurately according to similarity of action; or if the troublesome symptoms be not very violent, the next remedy must be given immediately, in order to take the place of the improperly selected one.

    Attributes of the True Healing Artist

    1. Pure Experience Over Speculation
    Relies on well-observed provings and clinical feedback rather than philosophical or metaphysical theories.
    2. Symptom Totality as the Sole Guide
    Treats the summed ensemble of sensations and modalities, not isolated or local symptoms alone.
    3. Gentle, Rapid, Permanent Cures
    Seeks remedies that restore health in the shortest, least harmful way, according to comprehensible principles.
    4. Respect for the Patient’s Vitality
    Uses potency and repetition tailored to each individual’s sensitivity, ensuring the vital force drives the cure, not the medicine.

    Next, you might explore practical steps to cultivate these qualities in your daily practice or case-taking techniques that unveil the totality of symptoms.

    See less
      • 0
    • Share
      Share
      • Share on Facebook
      • Share on Twitter
      • Share on LinkedIn
      • Share on WhatsApp
1 … 13 14 15 … 88

Sidebar

Ask A Question

Stats

  • Questions 2k
  • Answers 2k
  • Posts 26
  • Comments 4
  • Best Answers 11
  • Users 6k
  • Groups 13
  • Group Posts 4
  • Popular
  • Answers
  • Esrat

    Explanation Hahnemann's work from materialistic, spiritualistic, idealistic or vitalistic ...

    • 4 Answers
  • Dr Beauty Akther

    What are the aims of philosophy?

    • 2 Answers
  • Dr Beauty Akther

    Write down the different method of dynamisation.

    • 3 Answers
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Selection of Dose and Potency in Acute vs. Chronic Disease:… July 13, 2026 at 2:04 pm
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Case Taking in Homoeopathy: The Holistic Lens In homoeopathy, case… July 13, 2026 at 1:40 pm
  • Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH
    Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH added an answer Primary Manifestation of Psora — Homoeopathic View The Core Idea… July 13, 2026 at 1:19 pm

Top Members

Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH

Dr Md shahriar kabir B H M S; MPH

  • 0 Questions
  • 764 Points
Enlightened
Dr Beauty Akther

Dr Beauty Akther

  • 365 Questions
  • 148 Points
Pundit
Zannat

Zannat

  • 83 Questions
  • 27 Points
Begginer

Questions Categories

Disease
33Followers
Repertory
26Followers
Materia Medica
33Followers
Pathology
32Followers
Case taking
27Followers
Miasma
27Followers
Homoeopathic philosophy
25Followers
Organon
26Followers
Gynecology
31Followers
Microbiology
31Followers
Psychology
23Followers
Surgery
31Followers
Public Health
24Followers
Homoeopathic pharmacy
23Followers
Language
17Followers
Homoeopathy
19Followers
Obstetrics
24Followers
Human Behavior
27Followers
Research Methodology
19Followers
Analytics
21Followers
Physiology
16Followers
Forensic Medicine
21Followers
Technology
29Followers
Education
32Followers
Health
31Followers
Management
20Followers
Food & health
22Followers
Human Progress
25Followers
Hypothetical Personal Situations
21Followers
Dreams and Dreaming
33Followers
History
7Followers
Programmers
17Followers
The Holly Quran
13Followers
The Noble Quran
13Followers
Tissue remedies
21Followers
Anatomy
15Followers
Company
18Followers
Visiting and Travel
28Followers
University
17Followers
Reading
21Followers
Grammar
24Followers
Programs
17Followers
Communication
18Followers
Contents
Last update: 13/05/26

Explore

  • Questions
  • Complaint
  • Groups
  • Blog

Footer

mdpathyqa

mdpathyqa is a social & Answers Engine which will help you establis your community and connect with other people.

Help

  • Knowledge Base
  • Knowledge Base
  • Support
  • Support

Follow

Footer 1

2024 microdoshomoeo. All Rights Reserved
With Love by microdoshomoeo

Latest Activity: discuss about selection of dose and potency in case of acute and chronic disease.